New Haven Style Pizza
& Catering in Milford, CT

OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK • DINE IN OR TAKE OUT

GET DIRECTIONS

BIG BOY TRIVIA EVERY MONDAY: 6PM-8PM • ALWAYS FREE • ALWAYS GREAT PRIZES

Welcome to Jimmy’s Apizza!

A local favorite for over 20 years.

Now freshly remodeled and reopened as of January 2025, Jimmy’s is better than ever — with a brand-new look, the same great flavor, and even more space to enjoy it. Whether you’re grabbing a slice at the counter, settling in at a table with the kids, or soaking up the sun in our outdoor seating area, there’s always a spot for you — and plenty of parking to make getting here easy.

And we’ve got even more to celebrate: thanks to your support, Jimmy’s was named Best Pizza in the Region!

We’re truly honored and grateful to everyone who voted. Our customers feel like family, and we’re proud to be part of this small city with a big heart. Thank you for letting us do what we love — we can’t wait to keep serving you!

Check out Our Menus

Everything made fresh and to order

APPS

PIZZA

PASTA

GRINDERS

SALADS

Jimmy's Apizza

4.7

Based on 405 reviews

1 month ago

1 month ago

1 month ago

1 month ago

Me & my family were in town for the labor weekend and we heard good things about this place so we decided to head over for a early dinner. This is probably one of if not the best Apizza I ever had! Better than Frank Pepe's, better than some of the barstool pizzas where I'm from Along with the French onion soup, this place deserves a 5 stars! Would definitely recommend if anyone who is in the New Haven area to check this place out.

IMMACULATE CARPETCARE

1 month ago

Amanda Showalter

3 months ago

We were just passing through, and my husband insisted on trying authentic New Haven pizza. The problem? We were in a 42' RV, which was not conducive to stopping in town for lunch. I called Jimmy's to order, with the plan of hopping out, grabbing the pizza, and continuing on our way. It was ready by the time we got there, fresh and hot. Granted, we ate it at a rest stop, but it was still delicious, and our group quickly devoured the two pies we ordered. Hopefully we can come back someday and enjoy the restaurant, but we're glad we got to try it on our trip!

4 months ago

4 months ago

4 months ago

4 months ago

If you're a NYer and don't like Frank Pepe for whatever reason, this is your pizza! Great crust with the familiar Queens / Brooklyn topping. Heaven!

Michael Kelly

5 months ago

Great pizza.

docgraham

5 months ago

A casual and very nice place to have a bite. Staff is super friendly. Place is immaculate. You can see the attention to service. Pizzas are fantastic with that great crust crunch and they don't skimp on the toppings. Wine, beer and soft drinks available. Great value.

Pastor Edwin Soto

6 months ago

I had a great experience at Jimmy’s Pizzeria! I came with my family and everything was enjoyable from start to finish. We ordered the bruschetta to start, and it was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. For our main, we had a medium Kennedy pie, which was absolutely delicious — the crust was just right, and the toppings were generous and full of flavor. The atmosphere was welcoming and perfect for a family outing, and the service was friendly and attentive. You can really tell they care about the quality of their food and the experience they provide. Definitely a place I’d come back to and recommend to others! 🍕

Jessie Friend

7 months ago

Quick trip back to CT and straight to Sally’s. One bite and you remember why New Haven pizza has a cult following. That coal-fired crust, perfect char, zero nonsense — just absolute mastery. Some places chase trends. Sally’s been quietly making the best pizza on earth for 100 years. Transcendent pie. 🍕

ninjracer1

11 months ago

I went for a lunch and ordered a small Cheese and Sausage pizza, I didn't know what to expect but was extremely happy. The pizza tasted Fresh and delicious. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone.

Renee Majors

12 months ago

The service was excellent from start to finish—every staff member was friendly, welcoming, and genuinely happy to be there. You can tell they really care about their customers. The food came out hot, fresh, and delicious, and the portions were huge—definitely great value for the price. The pizza had that perfect balance of flavor and crispness, and everything we tried tasted homemade and authentic.

Jeff Mortenson

1 year ago

Wow! My first experience with New Haven style and I can see why Portnoy loves it. Great crust, little flop, sauce was spot on. He only gave them an 8.1 (which is solid for him), I said they were an 8.2. Service was superb, couldn't ask for better service. The French Onion Soup was absolutely delicious. We also had the garlic knots, which were the best I've had. The garlic sauce and marinara mingled a sweet dance on my taste buds, get them, you won't be disappointed. The only thing I regret is I didn't get a hoodie to take home, maybe they will reach out and let me know how I can get one 😁 DO NOT pass on Jimmy's Apizza.

Helen Loomis

1 year ago

This place is amazing! I live a town over from New Haven and used to work on a pizza truck, so I know good pizza and this is it! The crust alone gets 5 stars! So far I've tried sausage, pepperoni, plain, mashed potato and their stuffed bread, all delicious!

Louis Vieira

1 year ago

Pat Cassella

1 year ago

One of the best pizza places in Connecticut. Got there at 5pm looking for just a single slice, but they stop at 3 o'clock. They were nice enough to cook me up a small within 8 minutes, and it was spectacular. Great crust and cooked, just right. I would absolutely recommend it, and this is from a local whose fav is Zuppardis in West Haven..

Jacqueline Rivera

1 year ago

We got 1/2 cheese and pepperoni pizza, Bbq wings with ranch.. Our 1st time try Jimmy’s apizza( we are from MA) They are delicious! Very enjoyable.. thank you Jimmy’s apizza..

Ryan Burlone

1 year ago

Ordered out. Pizza is good. Would I drive from South Stratford to buy it again? Provably not. Three Pizzas and chicken tenders and fries. 90$ Woof Faaa……

D00009 w

2 years ago

Delicious crispy pizza

Frannk Sannicola

2 years ago

Love this place. Ordered pizza for the guys I'm working with on the UI project next to the train tracks.

Billy Klubek

2 years ago

We always get a pizza with sausage and garlic. Just keeps you coming about for more.

maricel zamora

2 years ago

Tasty food and friendly service. I like the weekly specials, keeps it intriguing to know what’s coming out next! My toddler loves their pizza, I wish they offered slices of pizza for kids all the time and not just at lunch time. My toddler won’t eat a whole pizza but a slice is just right. So usually we pop in for lunch instead of dinner because of it not being an option during dinner time. Overall great food and great ambiance.

Rebecca Marquis

2 years ago

My husband came in for a pickup of pizza and a grinder. We were told to pick up at 645pm. Husband arrived at 7pm due to an unexpected accident and the rude woman behind the counter had the audacity to begin reprimanding him for being late. ARE YOU SERIOUS? We did just fine while you were closed for renovation. Bye Bye Now. You should check your helps attitude. We were long-time customers. Not anymore. ??

New Haven Style Pizza & Catering in Milford, CT

OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK • DINE IN OR TAKE OUT

BIG BOY TRIVIA EVERY MONDAY: 6PM-8PM • ALWAYS FREE • ALWAYS GREAT PRIZES

Welcome to Jimmy’s Apizza!

A local favorite for over 20 years.

Check out Our Menus

Everything made fresh and to order

New Haven Style Pizza
& Catering in Milford, CT